Jonas Kuster Posted January 1, 2020 at 04:16 PM Posted January 1, 2020 at 04:16 PM I'm getting a "not closed border lines error" when loading the sectors for EURW which I cannot understand why it is generated. I would appreciate some other people familiar with working ESE files could have a look into it. The exact error message is: Error: Not closed border lines LFMM·LFMM FIR·000·195/1753/1320 in line 33591 The borderline referenced to is the following (the line starting with "BORDER"): SECTOR:LFMM·LFMM FIR·000·195:00000:19500 OWNER:FM BORDER:1753:1315:1354:1355:1356:1357:1348:635:634:1361:1308:1513:1757:1758:1759:1760:1761:1762:1449:1450:1451:1371:1378:1452:1280:1281:1763:1288:1287:1286:1285:1435:1434:1764:1553:1549:1667:850:1666:1395:195:194:1397:1724:1383:1382:1381:1324:1320:1723:1062:1313 DEPAPT:LFKB:LFKC:LFKF:LFKJ:LFLB:LFLL:LFLS:LFLU:LFLY:LFMD:LFMN:LFTW:LFLC:LFMA:LFMI:LFML:LFMO:LFMV:LFMP:LFMT:LFMU:LFTW:LFTH ARRAPT:LFKB:LFKC:LFKF:LFKJ:LFLB:LFLL:LFLS:LFLU:LFLY:LFMD:LFMN:LFTW:LFLC:LFMA:LFMI:LFML:LFMO:LFMV:LFMP:LFMT:LFMU:LFTH:LFTW The mentioned points in the error message (1753 and 1320) do not reflect the actual first and last bits of the border definitition. 1753 is the first one, but 1320 is not the last. So it is correct that these two sectorlines do not close the sector. It would be 1313 that closes with 1753, which I verified. So why does ES think that 1320 should close the sector? Is there a limit for the items forming the border definition? Here some extracts from the sectorline definitions to show that I would not expect an error. SECTORLINE:1753 ; GLO20891-GLO937 COORD:N046.30.00.000:E004.24.00.000 COORD:N046.30.00.000:E003.16.00.000 SECTORLINE:1320 ; GLO27306-GLO27307 COORD:N044.53.04.000:E003.01.57.000 COORD:N045.13.24.000:E003.01.16.000 SECTORLINE:1324 ; GLO27306-GLO841 COORD:N044.53.04.000:E003.01.57.000 COORD:N044.37.29.000:E003.02.28.000 SECTORLINE:1313 ; GLO843-GLO937 COORD:N046.20.00.000:E002.55.00.000 COORD:N046.30.00.000:E003.16.00.000 Any ideas appreciated. Jonas Kuster Network Supervisor Leader Operation vACC Switzerland | vacc.ch @vaccswitzerland GNG Support Team | gng.aero-nav.com ES Plugin Developer | CCAMS Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mark Walsh Posted January 2, 2020 at 10:36 PM Posted January 2, 2020 at 10:36 PM I would [Mod - Happy Thoughts]ume that you should have connected lines between 1753 and 1320. Need to see the lines 1723,1062 and 1313. [Mod - Happy Thoughts]uming the lines are not connected between these. This looks like GNG. If you use the map function, you should be able to see it better. Mark Walsh Vatsim Network Supervisor Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jonas Kuster Posted January 4, 2020 at 10:06 PM Author Posted January 4, 2020 at 10:06 PM Yes, it looks like ES is expecting that this border closes between 1753 and 1320, where it actually isn't. I can't understand why. It is a GNG generated file. But I couldn't find any incorrect definition that would explain the error shown by ES to me. So I think it's not the time yet to involve GNG staff. Here are the remaining line definitions: SECTORLINE:1723 ; GLO27307-GLO844-GLO27308 COORD:N045.13.24.000:E003.01.16.000 COORD:N045.42.45.000:E003.00.16.000 COORD:N046.15.19.000:E002.55.39.998 SECTORLINE:1062 ; GLO27308-GLO843 COORD:N046.15.19.000:E002.55.39.998 COORD:N046.20.00.000:E002.55.00.000 SECTORLINE:1313 ; GLO843-GLO937 COORD:N046.20.00.000:E002.55.00.000 COORD:N046.30.00.000:E003.16.00.000 Jonas Kuster Network Supervisor Leader Operation vACC Switzerland | vacc.ch @vaccswitzerland GNG Support Team | gng.aero-nav.com ES Plugin Developer | CCAMS Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mark Walsh Posted January 14, 2020 at 12:39 PM Posted January 14, 2020 at 12:39 PM Here is what I see SECTORLINE:1753 ; GLO20891-GLO937 COORD:N046.30.00.000:E004.24.00.000 COORD:N046.30.00.000:E003.16.00.000 [NEED COMMON POINT WITH 1062 HERE] SECTORLINE:1062 ; GLO27308-GLO843 COORD:N046.15.19.000:E002.55.39.998 ; Connects to 1723 COORD:N046.20.00.000:E002.55.00.000 [NEED COMMON POINT WITH 1753 HERE] SECTORLINE:1723 ; GLO27307-GLO844-GLO27308 COORD:N045.13.24.000:E003.01.16.000 ; Connects to 1320 COORD:N045.42.45.000:E003.00.16.000 COORD:N046.15.19.000:E002.55.39.998 ; Connects to 1062 SECTORLINE:1320 ; GLO27306-GLO27307 COORD:N044.53.04.000:E003.01.57.000 ; Connects to 1324 COORD:N045.13.24.000:E003.01.16.000 ; Connects to 1723 Mark Walsh Vatsim Network Supervisor Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jonas Kuster Posted April 20, 2020 at 08:20 PM Author Posted April 20, 2020 at 08:20 PM Felix from the GNG team did some tests and identified the following (undocumented) limitation by EuroScope, which is a maximum of 49 lines for a sector. If there are 50 or more, the remaining ones are disregarded, hence the error displayed. Conclusion: If you get the following error displayed in ES, it might be that the sector mentioned has more than 49 lines for it's definition. Error: Not closed border lines ... You need to reduce the number of lines. Easiest is by dividing the concerned sector in two. Then you will have two sectors to display. However, the limitation is on the lines per sector, which will then be about half. Jonas Kuster Network Supervisor Leader Operation vACC Switzerland | vacc.ch @vaccswitzerland GNG Support Team | gng.aero-nav.com ES Plugin Developer | CCAMS Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jonas Kuster Posted January 4, 2021 at 06:32 PM Author Posted January 4, 2021 at 06:32 PM For anyone coming across this issue, the limit has been lifted to 200 in the r25 version. Jonas Kuster Network Supervisor Leader Operation vACC Switzerland | vacc.ch @vaccswitzerland GNG Support Team | gng.aero-nav.com ES Plugin Developer | CCAMS Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts