Jump to content

You're browsing the 2004-2023 VATSIM Forums archive. All content is preserved in a read-only fashion.
For the latest forum posts, please visit https://forum.vatsim.net.

Need to find something? Use the Google search below.

X-Plane vs MSFS2004


Martin Tait 908838
 Share

Recommended Posts

Martin Tait 908838
Posted
Posted

Good Afternoon,

 

i was at KLAX (Los Angeles Intl) a few nights ago, preparing to contact the ATC for my departure and i noticed there was a B747 parked at the gate next to me.

 

the B747 appeared half way above the ground and half underneath , why did this happen every other aircraft looks normal. the only thing i could put it down to was, i am using MSFS2004 and i am guessing he/she was using X-Plane

 

also, when they were taxiing it was if there runways,taxiways were in a different place to

 

any thoughts?

British Airways | B737 | EGLL

logo-red-small.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Norman Blackburn
Posted
Posted

Chances are since it was a 747 what you saw was PS1.3, a sim dedicated only to the 747-400.

 

Check out their site @ www.aerowinx.de

 

Priced at GBP 169.95 from RCSims in the UK or you could take advantage buying from the USA @ $259.95

Norman

sig_FSLBetaTester.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Martin Tait 908838
Posted
Posted

when changeing money from USA Dollers to GBP the cost is (roughly) half isnt it depending on the rate?

only roughly i mean

British Airways | B737 | EGLL

logo-red-small.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Norman Blackburn
Posted
Posted

Roughly speaking, yes.

Norman

sig_FSLBetaTester.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Martin Tait 908838
Posted
Posted

ok thanks

British Airways | B737 | EGLL

logo-red-small.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...
Keith Smith
Posted
Posted

1) MSFS and Xplane report their altitudes relative to different points on the aircraft

 

2) the airplane may not have been a 747. The mappings in xsquawkbox don't cover all aircraft, and if memory serves, it falls back to the 747.

 

3) the taxiway layouts aren't 100% accurate for all airports...but they're getting better over time.

 

Keith

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Christopher Serio 823884
Posted
Posted
1) MSFS and Xplane report their altitudes relative to different points on the aircraft

 

2) the airplane may not have been a 747. The mappings in xsquawkbox don't cover all aircraft, and if memory serves, it falls back to the 747.

 

3) the taxiway layouts aren't 100% accurate for all airports...but they're getting better over time.

 

Keith

 

Keith's answer is pretty accurate. There's a few issues causing this but the main two are as follows...

 

1) XSB determines the aircraft's position (elevation) based on its center of gravity. This may vary in from sim to sim. So if FS2004 uses a different reference point, then the aircraft will appear above/below the ground.

 

2) The second issue is model matching. If the real user was flying an A340 for example and you didn't have a multiplayer model of an A340 to draw, XSB might pick a B747 as the closest match. But the height from the Center of Gravity to the ground between the A340 and B747 may be different.

 

These two issues combined account for most of the error.

Christopher Serio,

Developer XTower/AVC/XSB/ACSim (Sweatbox)

667.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
Ethan Stein 890841
Posted
Posted

Will XSB ever be able to display the livery of the aircraft? Just wondering, I'm starting to understand how all this works and it seems it would be very difficult. Yet SB3 does it outstanding for MSFS as I hear, so I was just wondering how much different it would be.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share